JUSTIN HAYES | Guest columnist
Nov 4, 2026
Water sustains southern Idaho agriculture and its communities. But prolonged drought is making it harder to plan. Water users face restrictions and costly adjustments. Some are considering new storage, including rebuilding Teton Dam, which failed catastrophically in 1976. Before pursuing an expensive, controversial dam whose reservoir may not reliably fill, Idaho should consider another option: removing four dams in Washington.
The lower Snake River dams are usually discussed as a salmon issue. But they also a!ect Idaho's water supply. Each year, the Bureau of Reclamation provides up to 487,000 acre-feet of upper Snake River water to help young salmon and steelhead migrate downstream. That's water Idaho farmers could use.
Breaching the dams and restoring a free-flowing lower Snake could reduce the need for those releases. It wouldn't automatically free that water for irrigation; water rights and federal obligations would require negotiation. Nevertheless, the possibility of keeping more water in Idaho deserves attention.
Idaho's fish also urgently need help. Idaho Fish and Game reported that this year's steelhead return at Bonneville Dam was the lowest since counts began in 1938. Despite decades of recovery efforts, wild runs remain perilously low.
These are Idaho's fish, returning to the Salmon and Clearwater rivers and sustaining businesses, communities and tribal fishing traditions. They are part of our culture and river-based economy. Fisheries scientists identify breaching as essential to rebuilding these runs, alongside other measures.
Understandably, Idaho farmers worry about their downstream neighbors. Grain growers use barges to reach export markets, and nobody wants to help Idaho farmers by imposing new costs on others. Washington state is examining alternatives.
A Washington State Department of Transportation study evaluates ways to move grain now shipped by barge. One rail- focused scenario finds that an expanded regional network could handle wheat currently barged on the lower Snake while reducing truck miles. Rail is already familiar: roughly two-thirds of wheat reaching Columbia River export terminals arrives by train.
The study shows that replacing barge service would require investment in rail lines, terminals and infrastructure. If farmers face higher freight bills, those costs shouldn't be shifted onto them. A dedicated, adequately funded program should o!set increases and hold farmers harmless.
Congressman Mike Simpson's 2021 salmon recovery framework advanced that principle: replace the services the dams provide rather than leave communities absorbing losses. Washington's research is starting to show what that could involve.
Our future need not pit farmers against fish, or Idaho irrigators against Washington wheat growers. A credible regional solution can maintain a!ordable freight service, reliable power, and other benefits while restoring fish and exploring opportunities to retain Idaho water.
Washington is preparing for the possibility of dam removal. Before Idaho invests enormous sums in new storage, we should ask whether removing four downstream dams could help secure water for Idaho farms and restore the salmon and steelhead that belong to all Idahoans.
Justin Hayes is the Northern Rockies conservation director for American Rivers, a conservation organization working to make every river clean and healthy for people and wildlife. For more information, visit AmericanRivers.org.
Post Register: Opinion: Could removing four dams help Idaho farmers?

